93 Days Until Election Day
California Governor
Status: Democrat Open
2024 Presidential Result: Blue State (West)
Outlook: Likely Democrat
The election for Governor of the nation's most populous state feels like a foregone conclusion at this point for the most part, but it was quite a complicated series of events to reach this somewhat anticlimactic point. California is an extremely blue state but that does not mean that a whole lot of people within it do not want change from the status quo. That is leaving me at this point to classify the race as Likely Democrat but I will not be surprised if post Labor Day polling will have me change it to Safe D. Regardless, races for the U.S. House, in recently redrawn districts and even the all Democrat runoff for Los Angeles Mayor are likely to get more headlines the rest of this cycle that a result that is likely to see California elect its first Latino Governor.
For starters, incumbent Governor Gavin Newsom is term-limited after two terms (and successfully winning a recall election too) and cannot run again. Over the past year plus, he has relished his role as a target and fierce critic of Donald Trump. This is clearly in line with someone who plans to run for his party's Presidential nomination. Newsom is definitely headed in that direction and has the sort of name recognition that places him near the top of many national polls for Democrats.Whether he will actually succeed or flop as a national candidate is a topic for next year that I will likely discuss then. For now, while Newsom brags of many successes leading California, there have been many issues that have hurt his profile in the state, at least since the Covid pandemic including the state's resources, destructive fires, and the state of the economy. It also appear that the federal Justice Department is trying to move legally against one of Trump's political enemies and may be targeting Newsom's wife in the process. For someone running as a Democrat for President, Newsom might not might all this.
The race for Governor this year has been a whole lot about who decided not to run. Many who did not probably wish they had at this point as they may have become the Democrat who advanced to the November election. These people include former Vice President Kamala Harris, who seems to have put more focus on another run for President, and current U.S. Senator Alex Padilla. The state's Attorney General did not run for Governor and neither did a recent interim U.S. Senator. Also not running was Rick Caruso, a moderate Democrat and wealthy businessman who lost a competitive race for Mayor of Los Angeles in 2022. He did not run for Governor or Mayor this year even though he might have found this a better year for political success.
Eleni Kounalakis, the current Lt. Governor, a job Newsom had prior to his election, did jump in to the contest, but not getting anywhere decided to run for State Treasurer instead. Had she stayed in the race for Governor, it is possible she could have been a contender near the end. Two Asian-American statewide elected females were at one point in the mix. Treasurer Fiona Ma got in and out of the race early and is instead the likely next Lt. Governor. Former Controller Betty Yee got into the race and got out late when her campaign was stuck in neutral and party leaders were calling for some of the many Democrats to exit the field. Another statewide elected official, Tony Thurmond, the Education Commissioner and the only major party main black candidate in the race stayed in and could not even quite touch 1 percent one June 2 in the all candidate jungle primary. It is sort of hard for me to believe that these candidates, who had won statewide office before, just could not even compete in a Gubernatorial race,
For a while, it looked like Democrats had a frontrunner in Eric Swalwell, a Congressman from the Bay Area, who made a name for himself as a frequent critic of Trump in Washington,. He would go on to receive many endorsements but also had rumors swirling around him. As the primary approached, he was accused of sexual harassment and assault by a series of women who were Democrats. He denied doing anything illegal, while admitting to making mistakes in his marriage, but his supporters started dropping their support, and he quickly had to exit the race at that point, as well as resigning his seat in Congress. Swalwell may ultimately face criminal charges.
A major topic of discussion in this race was what would happen if so many Democrats on the ballot split the vote to such an extent where the only two Republicans of note in the race managed to finish first and second locking the Democrats out for November. This would have been a catastrophe for the party as Republicans salivated about it being their only possible way of winning the Governorship. Some other Democrats did heed the call to drop out, but once Swalwell, it appeared to be fairly certain that at least one Democrat, and maybe even two would finish at the top. It is worth nothing that none of these Democrats were really running on a platform to continue the legacy of Gavin Newsom. They all seemed to have serious criticisms of him and the outgoing Governor apparently feels the same way. That sort of lack of support within his own party in his own state is not exactly a great political situation for a Presidential candidate to have.
After Swalwell was out, it looked like Katie Porter, a combative Congresswoman, who had failed to make a U.S. Senate general election in 2024 could become the top Democrat. She was the last remaining major female candidate in the race, but her campaign fizzled. For months, she faced questions about her temperament, a nasty divorce, and how she treated her staff, especially after a video surfaced of her cursing out an employee for "getting in her shot" during a taped television piece.
Finishing behind Porter in sixth place overall in June was Matt Mahan, a technology entrepreneur and the Mayor of San Jose, who positioned himself as a fairly pragmatic Democrat. That sort of thing ultimately was not selling this year, at least in California. Antonio Villaraigosa, also tried to move slightly to the right on some cultural issues, but the 73 year old former Mayor of Los Angeles, who was making his second bid for Governor, went nowhere also. He finished in seventh place with one percent of the vote. One fun fact is that exactly 25 years earlier, Villaraigosa advanced to a runoff in his first campaign for Mayor of Los Angeles (and would eventually lose that year) where the last place candidate and his fellow Latino then Congressman Xavier Becerra, finished way back in last place. The roles would definitely be reversed statewide when the two competed a quarter of a century later.
The homestetch saw the battle for Democrats coming down to Becerra, who after many years in Congress left to become California's Attorney General, won an election to that office in his own right, and then was picked by Joe Biden to be Secretary of Health and Human Services. There was also Tom Steyer, a liberal billionaire, who had sought the Presidential nomination in 2024 and in this race for Governor poured money into television ads. While both candidates were quite liberal, Steyer was definitely even further tot the left. (I would have voted for Mahan I suppose.) The battle between these two men became pretty nasty as Steyer was accused of trying to buy the election, plus his status as a billionaire which is not exactly a popular thing to be among today's progressives. Becerra, who came from a working class background as the son of parents who grew up in Mexico, was accused of having past ethical problems and of being ineffective in public office. It was claimed that he was basically bypassed by the Biden Administration as HHS Secretary, in regards to the handling of the Covid pandemic, with responsibilities he might have been expected to have going to others. It is true that several prominent Biden alumni seemed agnostic to downright opposed to Becerra being his party's best candidate for Governor.
Of course Republicans have to be mentioned also in this race. While a slew of Independent, third party candidates, and little known Democrats and Republicans were on the June ballot, only two more candidates were important to watch. For a time, it looked like the Republican establishment would be lining up behind Chad Bianco, the mustachioed Sheriff of Riverside County. Then Steve Hilton got into the race, hoping to follow in the footsteps of another European immigrant with an accent and first time candidate who got elected Governor as a Republican. Hilton came from England where he became a top political aide to David Cameron, a one-time Conservative Party Prime Minister of Great Britain. Hilton moved to California in 2012 and became a U.S. citizen in 2021. He renounced his British citizenship last year.
In the states, Hilton became a contributor to Fox News, where the bald pundit would frequently appear wearing black t-shirts (perhaps a la Simon Cowell.) Nowadays, Hilton has a beard and wears ties more frequently. I do not quite understand how Hilton became so popular in conservative circles to the extent where he had so many people in California supporting him for Governor, but that is what happened. He then received the endorsement of Donald Trump, which would clearly also mean a major blow to Bianco, and with it, any chance of two Republicans both getting enough votes to sneak into the general election. Many joined me in thinking that the Trump endorsement of Hilton was quite politically dumb for that reason, but I quickly assessed my thinking and realized that the White House probably assumed that such a particular event was not going to happen anyway and if nothing else, propping up Hilton meant that at least one Republican would be around in November. Bianco and Hilton continued to do battle though, sometimes with both appearing on debate stages alongside the several major Democrats, and that made for interesting television. Both stuck pretty close to the MAGA talking points, which was needed to win California Republican primary voters, but definitely not helpful in a general election. Both expressed a hardline position on immigrants, which is of course ironic since Hilton is himself a recent immigrant.
When it came time for the voting in early June there were many questions about who would advance and who might play spoiler. It also takes California a good deal of time to count its votes, although this year, the result may have come somewhat earlier than expected. Ultimately, Becerra finished first with 28 percent and Hilton held off Steyer for the second slot 25-23. Bianco finished with 10 percent and nobody else even received five percent. Before the runoff spot was clinched for Hilton, many Republicans feared he would be shut out of it and Donald Trump said that California officials were trying to steal a victory from him, just as they did for the goofball he endorsed for Mayor of Los Angeles who days after the vote fell from second place to third. (Spencer Pratt would have finished second probably if Trump did not endorse him.) Hilton not being screwed out of a November place on the ballot might to some logical people suggest the election was fair but Trump has persisted that Hilton was only allowed to advance to throw people off the scent of other crimes, such as the LA Mayor's race. Craziness all around. Hilton has not joined this particular kind of conspiracy theory in regards to Los Angeles, which of course is more Democrat than the state of California is as a whole.
There is a lot to speculate though about if it might even be worth it for Hilton to still be in this race. While it is true that his presence might bring out some voters who would otherwise stay home and and that could help with down-ballot contests, months of a Steyer vs. Becerra general election, with an uncertain outcome, could have been bad news for Democrats. They would have been attacking each other on a daily basis with all sorts of money from around California and the country being invested into what would essentially be a primary, rather than going to other Democrats in other races. In this hypothetical, I think that whatever amount of Republicans who bothered to vote would have given the win to Becerra over Steyer. For months, his candidacy seemed be going nowhere, but when Swalwell imploded, and the other Democrats were not able to take advantage, Becerra was in the right position as the least objectionable alternative to many. Not exactly the stuff of political inspiration there, but a W is a W.
The general election is set though between an American born son of a Mexican immigrant and a British immigrant. That speaks well towards what America is about, but that does not mean these are two good candidates or that either of them will make a good Governor. California is simply not going to go far enough to the right to elect a Republican anytime soon but Hilton is good at delivering a message and many agree with him that change from the Newsom years would be welcome in regards to the economy and crime and many other things. Becerra and the Democrats will say that the real problem is Donald Trump and his allies and that is probably going to wind up as the more salient message.
Hilton will get at least 38 percent of the vote but probably not more than 42 percent. That makes all of this seem pretty non-dramatic. For better or worse, for his political party and for California itself, Xavier Becerra, at 68 years old, and after decades in politics, is poised to become the Golden State Governor, at least for one term.
Gubernatorial races predicted thus far:
3 D, (1 Likely, 1 Leans, 1 Tossup), 2 R (1 Safe, I Likely)
Totals predicted thus far:
9 D (6 holdover, 1 Likely, 1 Leans, 1 Tossup), 10 R (8 holdover, 1 Safe, 1 Likely)