Saturday, November 21, 2026

2026 Election Predictions Recap: Governors

The dust is beginning to settle but the ramifications are only beginning. Earlier this month, the Republican Party, (of which I was once a proud member) received one of the most severe electoral beatdowns in its history, and I was quite pleased to see it happen. This of course benefited the opposition Democrats (a party I have never belonged to and have no intention of joining) but the reality is that this vote nationwide was mostly one cast to oppose Donald Trump, both politically and personally, and not a sign of any great ideological shift leftward or towards Democrats.
 
While massive House and Senate pickups were most of the national story, and I will detail those and formally check my predictions in the weeks ahead, Democrats also won a lot of Gubernatorial contests as well as downballot statewide races, flipping legislative chambers, etc. As I have noted before, this was not as much a "blue tsunami" but an "Orange Chernobyl" and one particular man is responsible, and while everyone realizes it, he will not admit it. Time will tell what will become of Republicans as Trumpism marches more and more towards its lame duck conclusion, but that will be a discussion for next year.
 
Now, I am just going to list my incorrect Gubernatorial predictions and briefly explain why I may have been wrong. Overall, I did really well, at least in concert with most predictors, at least in this category.
 
Kansas: 
At one point, this race looked like it leaned towards a rare Republican pickup this cycle. In the final days, I was able to recognize it was a Tossup but had predicted that Ty Masterson would benefit from the ticket-splitters that would at the same time deliver a U.S. Senate seat to the Democrats for the first time in nearly a century.

While that happened, the overall environment was enough to deliver the Governorship narrowly to Democrat Cindy Holscher, Democrats also managed to win the race for Attorney General, unseating the nationally prominent but divisive Republican incumbent. Even Bob Dole's homestate was not immune to the "blue wave." Tariffs and high fuel prices hit the economy of Kansas hard as did the deportation of many Hispanics who had comprised a significant part of the state's workforce in some sectors. 
 
Think about it though. Even as most were expecting a very strong year for Democrats, a term-limited Democrat as Governor, whom many had considered a fluke winner, was expected to still yield the office to a Republican, as Kansas has overall been a very Republican state. Donald Trump endorsed the eventual Republican nominee in a crowded primary, and while some of the defeated candidates probably could have won this race, his choice went on to lose and now Kansas has another Democrat female as Governor, who is at least slightly more to the left than the one who is leaving. Kansas Republicans certainly have a problem that cannot be ignored that goes beyond finally losing a Senate seat. They have now lost the Governorship in three straight elections and five out of the last seven. Many members of the party, including past Governors and Senators, have been endorsing Democrats also.
 
Texas:
It has been said for so long by so many but it was certainly true that no Democrat had won a statewide race in Texas since 1994 and even longer since a victory for Governor or U.S. Senate. This year, Democrats won every statewide race on the ballot. Is Texas now blue permanently? Probably not, but it sure is going to look purple for a while to come and if Republicans cannot win the state in a Presidential election, they will be definitely be locked out of the White House.
 
Again, this is a Gubernatorial race that I thought was a Tossup that would go towards the Republican, at the same time a Democrat would break a long trend and narrowly pick up a U.S. Senate seat. This Senate race was not even close at the end and incumbent Governor Greg Abbott was denied his fourth them. That alone should be a warning, along with surprising losses of other Governors in both parties who were seeking such a term in states that do not have term limits. Eventually, voters just become tired of you.
 
In so many ways, this was a brutal cycle for Texas Republicans, who had to endure the anchor of Ken Paxton as their U.S. Senate nominee and that certainly helped sink Abbott. Donald Trump of course plays an even bigger role He is unpopular in Texas, a state he easily won two years ago, just as he is in a lot of states he carried in 2024. It must also be mentioned that Trump endorsed Paxton and thus holds a tremendous amount of responsibility for the specific electoral fate that fell upon all the Lone Star Republicans that lost.
 
It is very funny though that before the election people were saying that with all of Paxton's problems, there was no way he would lose to "Talafreako" because Texas was so red, and even if that race was closer than it should be, Abbott would still easily win the Governorship. Instead Abbott lost by seven points and in Gina Hinojosa, Texas has its first non-white Governor, and a Latina at that. Since I predicted this race was a Tossup, I was not incredibly shocked by who won, but I did not see a victory of this size coming. It is in many ways reminiscent of how in 1994 Republican George W. Bush unseated incumbent Ann Richards by seven points. That race was considered a Tossup going into Election Day, and people were surprised by the margin. Until this month, no Republican had really come close to losing the Governorship since.
 
The same people who were insisting that Texas was so red that even flawed Republicans would hang on in a tough environment are now claiming that no Republican would have been able to win those races this year. They may or may not right but from the redistricting gambit backfiring and everything else, it is hard to think of someone who had a worse year politically than Greg Abbott, whom on Election Night, found himself being attacked on Truth Social by Trump. At least Abbott gracefully conceded his defeat that night.
 
2026 Predictions: 34-2 (94%)
 

Past Results:

2006: 35-1 (97%)
2008: 10-1 (91%)
2010: 34-3 (92%)
2012: 9-2 (82%)
2014: 32-4 (89%)
2016: 9-3 (75%)
 
2018: 35-1 (97%) 
2020: 11-0 (100%) 
2022:  34-2 (94%)
2024: 11-0 (100%) 

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home